Should he stay or should he go?

I think he should go. I don't know if its financially possible but we've certainly passed the point of no return on the pitch.

I also now just cannot listen to him post-match. I used to enjoy it, but now I can only give it a minute before I have to turn it off. His arrogance and shock at being questioned is too much for me to stomach.

Has to go no home win site last December says it all - can't see where the next win is coming from and no confidence in Mccarthys tactics - I honestly believe I could swap my desk job and do better than that DVD watching Clown !

Because McCarthy doesn't realise that football is played on a pitch not a Subbuteo Table 

Would've voted no this morning but voted yes now. Personally, I've had enough, today was horrible and his post match interview is alarming in his stubbornness.

There was optimism with the signings but now the season has started and the reality has set in, he's built a piss poor squad for this league. We have a potentially decent starting XI but that's it, now injuries are picking up we are clearly in trouble. That is on Macca and Maguire's head.

We desperately need a lift, and it's only coming with change.

How is it even up to debate? The final straw was him turning around to have a go back at supporters who were well within their rights to voice their displeasure. It's been woeful for months, he signed decent players in the summer, we had a slight ounce of hope that things might improve. It's just not happening. He MUST go. If the board cannot see that he is badly damaging this clubs progress, then they ought to have a look at themselves. They had the chance to make the change in the summer (and given 2017's showing, nobody could have blamed them for pulling the trigger) but they failed to do so. The thing that worries me, as skint as we are (again, or so it appears) is that McCarthy is given the boot and replaced with Shaw and McIntyre for the fact they are the cheapest option. We've been down that route before after Burr was finally given the boot and look where it's got us.......

I can see Shaw being the replacement. It's a punt but he's already on the payroll and might be our only option, especially if he wants funds to bring anyone else in. Might be a punt worth taking, can't be any worse than what we have now

We all said exactly that when Burr left. I was unsure about McCarthy replacing him as I felt he was partly responsible for that mess. Gave him the benefit of the doubt following his first 15 games in charge, but now he's been found out and there is no way back for him. Shaw could be a revelation, we don't know, is it worth the risk? Mind you, to find out, we have actually got to get rid of McCarthy first and I can't see that happening just yet! 

I'd sack him tomorrow.

As others have astutely alluded to in other threads, we are simply kicking the can down the road by waiting any longer. I have never been so confident that in Jon McCarthy we have a manager who cannot turn this around.

1600 fans in the stadium today on our 3rd home game of the season says everything that needs to be said. Absolutely woeful. And he still has the arrogance to turn around and give the crowd verbals when we quite rightly voice our displeasure at what we are paying to watch.

The financial implications of attendances this low (and only heading in one direction) on a budget based on an average of circa 2100 home fans will be just as serious as the implications of removing the manager.

By my calculations, if we average 1,800 over the course of season (based on the current trajectory) - being generous, that would equate to a loss of £82,000.

At least if we sack the manager we will have a chance of retaining our status in this league and have a chance of getting our attendances back to what we quite rightly should be aiming for.

He wasn't too bad tonight actually and seemed to make a point about praising the support today. It's too late for that sort of bridge building though, especially when we cannot win at home. I think he knows he is on borrowed time. 

I would still have said "give him another five to six games" but on second thoughts, what would be the point? We know from the last eight months that he does not have the knowhow to turn it around. Delaying the inevitable as others have said. Sadly, he has to go.

I was worried after seeing us comprehensively outplayed by Alty in pre season. Even more worried 4 games into the league campaign. He does not see what everyone else sees, so why delay the inevitable?

i've gone for yes i did say give him till november however with his dross we could be long gone by then

There was one sat behind me today, arguing with fans letting McCarthy know their feelings.

A touch extreme perhaps, but there's no stopping any CFU member from calling an EGM with written notice - at which a motion could be proposed and then voted on.